diff --git a/docs/DECISIONS.md b/docs/DECISIONS.md
index be3ecca2..837807e5 100644
--- a/docs/DECISIONS.md
+++ b/docs/DECISIONS.md
@@ -719,3 +719,5 @@ One line per decision: date · decision · alternative · reason.
| 2026-11-04 | Global only: the new settings are not per-frame and not frame-keyed, so there are no new parked positions; the keyframe `Rotation` roll is unchanged. (Owner review 1, phase 4.) | Keyframed straighten or look | Simple, and roll already covers per-frame tilt. |
| 2026-11-04 | Phase 4 compatibility: new server + old node: v1 rendered by the node, v2 and proportions-win jobs never sent to it; old server + new desktop: v1 works, v2 push and render disabled with a reason, proportions-win render disabled (push works); new server + old desktop: v1 works, v2 listed and opened read-only, never mirrored or merged, the old desktop's own render uses the preset ratio (known limitation); old desktop local: v2 read-only, a format-1 `.chronos` refuses it, proportions-win renders at the preset ratio (CHANGELOG note). (Owner review 1, phase 4.) | — | Records the matrix the format, routing and gating rows give. |
| 2026-11-04 | Phase 4 groundwork details: `ProjectSettings.WrittenFormat` (the format `ToJson` stamps, a newer project's own number); `EditPath.HasHandValues` counts a crop only when not whole (`CropFrame.IsWhole`), which matches today; FrameFinish clamps the look strength to 0..1 (missing = 1) and an unknown look still writes format 2 (it is a newer Chronos's); look names are ordinal and case-sensitive; `OrientationEdit` also remaps offsets and pending keyframes, negates straighten on mirror/flip, normalises rotate to 0..270 and rounds remapped coordinates to 12 decimals so four turns give the original text; the SelfTest geometry and colour checks sit before the robustness checks. (Owner review 1, phase 4.) | — | Simplest safe choices where the plan was silent. |
+| 2026-11-04 | Phase 4 review fixes, routing and gates: render routing sizes a job from its resolved preset box, never from the size posted with it (the posted size only without a preset size); the server's wait for a node re-routes the job as the claim does; the remote editor lets edits happen but refuses to save settings the server cannot read (`NeedsNewerServer` toast); archive sync keeps such settings here (`ServerFormatException`, the row stays LocalAhead with the reason; the server's format is cached for 1 minute, none announced = 1); a workspace push is refused whole, before its first version, when any unpushed version needs a newer home, and Sync's reason includes the unpushed versions; a local render of a workspace project (`RendersLocally`) is not gated by the server's format; the Library's Render on a remote card applies the editor's older-server gate and sizes the job on the project it read, without embedding it (the server renders the sequence's settings of the moment). (Owner review 1, phase 4.) | Let the server refuse | Nothing an older server would store and then fail to render is sent to it, and no job waits for a node that never takes it. |
+| 2026-11-04 | Phase 4 review fixes, editing: a turn or mirror on one side and a framing edit on the other (crop, keyframes, offsets, aspect, keyframes of waiting photos) are one merge conflict at the orientation member, settled with that side's framing; the derived top-level `version` is no settings difference while both are at most this Chronos's; a quarter turn transposes the aspect text without reducing it (21:9 → 9:21); an out-of-range crop is turned as it renders (clamped first); off-grid crop and keyframe values land on the 12-decimal grid at their first press and the keyframe centre sliders write gridded values; the Rotation row shows the turn as seen (reversed while exactly one of Mirror and Flip is on); Reset framing undoes the orientation press by press so keyframes and aspect stay on their content; the look strength minimum is 1 % and 0 or less clears the look; motion vectors are computed without the look and the knee; the horizon advisor maps its rows through turn, flip, straighten and cover zoom (the mirror moves only columns); inside a box with no slack a press pans while zoomed and the middle button always pans; the selected box shows a 2 px Accent ring; translations of keys whose English meaning changed are deleted (English fallback) instead of new keys. (Owner review 1, phase 4.) | — | Simplest safe choices for the review's findings. |
diff --git a/docs/plans/or1-phase-4.md b/docs/plans/or1-phase-4.md
index ebeb2276..d9478c35 100644
--- a/docs/plans/or1-phase-4.md
+++ b/docs/plans/or1-phase-4.md
@@ -650,10 +650,10 @@ Then an adversarial review round and its fixes.
- **Proportions win changes existing outputs.** A v1 project with an explicit non-source aspect and a fixed preset changes size, for example an advised 9:16 portrait at 4K going from 3840×2160 to 2160×3840. It is not gated by the stored format. Routing and the desktop's server gating cover new servers and nodes; an older desktop still renders at the preset ratio. This is in the CHANGELOG and DECISIONS.
- **Format 2 is user-visible.** Older desktops open such projects read-only, and older servers refuse pushes and renders. This is intended by owner review 2 and pre-empted by the disabled buttons with a reason.
- **Portrait encoder limits.** 2160×3840 exceeds the MF software H.264 maximum of 4096×2304 and may stop matching nodes whose limits are not orientation-symmetric. P5 checks this on the PC, and the Export step shows the capped mark.
-- **Merge semantics.** One side's turn and the other side's crop edit conflict on `camera.crop`, because `OrientationEdit` rewrites it. Straighten and crop merge independently, which the cover zoom keeps valid. `FitCrop` stays as the safety net.
+- **Merge semantics.** One side's turn or mirror and the other side's framing edit (crop, keyframes, offsets, aspect, keyframes of waiting photos) are one conflict at the orientation member, settled with that side's framing. Straighten and crop merge independently, which the cover zoom keeps valid. `FitCrop` stays as the safety net.
- **Preview drift.** Shared Core calls (`RenderGeometry.ViewFor`/`For`, `FrameFinish`) and a PSNR parity test guard against it. That test runs only on Windows.
- **Source-framing cost.** A non-identity transform adds two resamples per preview picture. The identity fast path and the preview long-edge cap limit it, and a crop drag updates only the overlay.
-- **Cover zoom softens the picture**: about 1.27× at 15° on 16:9. It is folded into `WorkingLongEdge`, so the decode size compensates.
+- **Cover zoom softens the picture**: about 1.43× at 15° on 16:9 (cos 15° + 16/9 · sin 15°). It is folded into `WorkingLongEdge`, so the decode size compensates.
- **Linux CI skips App.Tests and screenshots.** All crop, orientation, size and look math lives in Core and is gated on Linux. The UI packages are verified on the PC, where 156 armed baselines must be re-accepted (fonts, Europe/Rome).
- **i18n removals.** A removed English key makes all 38 locales report orphans. Removals are concentrated in P6 with `i18n prune`. The rule of at most 3 words per label is checked only in review; `i18n check` enforces 30 characters.
- **Parallel overlap.** Ownership is fixed:
diff --git a/docs/ui/DESIGN.md b/docs/ui/DESIGN.md
index 95914fdc..e7ae8964 100644
--- a/docs/ui/DESIGN.md
+++ b/docs/ui/DESIGN.md
@@ -82,8 +82,10 @@ Label column left of controls: 116 px in panels, 180 px in Settings.
(1 px Text at 30 %).
- *Locked* (read-only, newer format, busy): drawn as Shown, no handles, drag pans.
Hit-test order: a handle within 6 screen px, the wipe divider, inside the box (move, SizeAll cursor), outside
- (pan). Cursors SizeNWSE/SizeNESW on corners, SizeWE/SizeNS on edges. Keyboard with the preview focused:
- arrows move 1 %, Shift+arrows 10 %, + and − resize 2 % about the centre. Double-click keeps Fit / 1:1.
+ (pan); inside a box that spans the view both ways a press pans while the view is zoomed, and the middle button always
+ pans. Cursors SizeNWSE/SizeNESW on corners, SizeWE/SizeNS on edges. Keyboard: a press on the box or Enter selects it
+ (2 px Accent ring outside the handles), Esc gives the arrows back to the frames; while selected, arrows move 1 %,
+ Shift+arrows 10 %, + and − resize 2 % about the centre. Double-click keeps Fit / 1:1.
- **Status glyphs**: `●` green Analysed · `○` faint Not analysed · `●` Proxies · `▶ n` rendered
· `●` accent Synced/Remote · `◐` amber Analysing · `▲ n` warnings · `✕ n` errors.
- **Chips**: 24 px pills, Card fill, Stroke border; selected/recommended = Accent border and text.
diff --git a/src/Chronos.App/Editor/CameraTab.cs b/src/Chronos.App/Editor/CameraTab.cs
index def13836..b3888ac9 100644
--- a/src/Chronos.App/Editor/CameraTab.cs
+++ b/src/Chronos.App/Editor/CameraTab.cs
@@ -37,13 +37,6 @@ public sealed class CameraTab : EditorTab
Refresh();
}
- ///
- /// The step's rows, top to bottom: Aspect (a change refits the crop, ),
- /// Rotation (a quarter turn per press, as the user sees the picture), Mirror, Flip, Straighten (±15°, the preview's
- /// grid while it is used), and the crop box as Crop size (a share of the largest box the aspect allows), Crop X and
- /// Crop Y (its centre within the frame's slack). The crop rows write the locked box itself with the offsets at 0, so a
- /// legacy crop placed by offsets is baked in at its first edit ().
- ///
///
/// The quarter turns the Rotation row shows, as the user sees them: the stored turn is that of the unmirrored picture,
/// which runs the other way while exactly one of Mirror and Flip is on (a mirror reverses the sense of a turn), so a
@@ -56,6 +49,13 @@ public sealed class CameraTab : EditorTab
return camera.Mirror ^ camera.Flip ? (4 - turns) % 4 : turns;
}
+ ///
+ /// The step's rows, top to bottom: Aspect (a change refits the crop, ),
+ /// Rotation (a quarter turn per press, as the user sees the picture), Mirror, Flip, Straighten (±15°, the preview's
+ /// grid while it is used), and the crop box as Crop size (a share of the largest box the aspect allows), Crop X and
+ /// Crop Y (its centre within the frame's slack). The crop rows write the locked box itself with the offsets at 0, so a
+ /// legacy crop placed by offsets is baked in at its first edit ().
+ ///
public static IReadOnlyList FramingRows(EditorSession session)
{
ArgumentNullException.ThrowIfNull(session);
diff --git a/src/Chronos.App/Library/LibraryActions.cs b/src/Chronos.App/Library/LibraryActions.cs
index bc3ea4d8..6f99ff4d 100644
--- a/src/Chronos.App/Library/LibraryActions.cs
+++ b/src/Chronos.App/Library/LibraryActions.cs
@@ -90,7 +90,7 @@ public sealed class LibraryActions(ShellViewModel shell)
shell.Notify(Loc.L("Library.Post.Failed"), newer);
return null;
}
- return new CreateJobRequest(RenderKind, [sequence.Id], ProcessingJobs.Render(sequence, export, width, height, project).ParametersJson);
+ return ServerRender(sequence, project, export, width, height);
}, JobKind.Render, sequence.DisplayTitle);
return;
}
@@ -210,6 +210,14 @@ public sealed class LibraryActions(ShellViewModel shell)
internal static string? ServerCannotRender(ProjectSettings project, ExportSettings export, int sourceWidth, int sourceHeight, int serverFormat) =>
Editor.ServerJobs.NeedsNewerServer(ProcessingJobs.RequiredFormat(project, export, sourceWidth, sourceHeight), serverFormat);
+ ///
+ /// The server render of a remote card: sized on (the settings just read), which it does not
+ /// embed, so the server renders the sequence's settings as they are when a node takes the job (the read may come from
+ /// this PC's proxy cache, older than the server's).
+ ///
+ internal static CreateJobRequest ServerRender(Sequence sequence, ProjectSettings project, ExportSettings export, int sourceWidth, int sourceHeight) =>
+ new(RenderKind, [sequence.Id], ProcessingJobs.Render(sequence with { SettingsJson = project.ToJson() }, export, sourceWidth, sourceHeight).ParametersJson);
+
/// Posts the job gives; nothing when it gives none (it said why).
private async Task PostAsync(Func> build, JobKind kind, string label)
{
diff --git a/tests/Chronos.App.Tests/Library/LibraryRenderGateTests.cs b/tests/Chronos.App.Tests/Library/LibraryRenderGateTests.cs
index 1442fb51..e8838c93 100644
--- a/tests/Chronos.App.Tests/Library/LibraryRenderGateTests.cs
+++ b/tests/Chronos.App.Tests/Library/LibraryRenderGateTests.cs
@@ -1,6 +1,9 @@
+using System.Text.Json;
using Chronos.App.Library;
using Chronos.Core.Localization;
+using Chronos.Core.Model;
using Chronos.Core.Project;
+using Chronos.Protocol;
using Chronos.Testing;
namespace Chronos.App.Tests.Library;
@@ -27,4 +30,23 @@ public sealed class LibraryRenderGateTests
Assert.Null(LibraryActions.ServerCannotRender(turned, turned.Export, 6000, 4000, ProjectSettings.CurrentVersion));
Assert.Null(LibraryActions.ServerCannotRender(portrait, portrait.Export, 6000, 4000, ProjectSettings.CurrentVersion));
}
+
+ ///
+ /// The remote card's render is sized on the project just read (the card's copy may be older: here 16:9 against 9:16) and
+ /// does not embed it, so the server renders the sequence's settings as they are when a node takes the job.
+ ///
+ [Test]
+ public void ARemoteRenderIsSizedOnTheProjectReadAndRendersTheServersSettings()
+ {
+ var project = new ProjectSettings { Export = Uhd(), Camera = new CameraSettings { Aspect = new Auto().WithManual("9:16") } };
+ var card = new Sequence { Id = Guid.NewGuid(), ArchiveId = Guid.NewGuid(), Folder = "harbour", SettingsJson = new ProjectSettings { Export = Uhd() }.ToJson() };
+
+ var request = LibraryActions.ServerRender(card, project, project.Export, 6000, 4000);
+
+ Assert.Equal(card.Id, request.Target.Single());
+ var parameters = JsonSerializer.Deserialize(request.ParametersJson!, ProtocolJson.Default.RenderJobParameters)!;
+ Assert.Equal((2160, 3840), (parameters.Width, parameters.Height));
+ Assert.Null(parameters.SettingsJson);
+ Assert.Equal(2, parameters.RequiredSettingsFormat);
+ }
}